Black eyeliner review

Evening people..tonight I am reviewing three black eye pencils I have in my kit. The pictures will speak for themselves really. On the first image from left to right is, Benefit Bad Gal eyeliner, Bourjois Smoky Ultra black eyeliner with brush and then on the right is Neal Yards organic eyeliner. I have also added pictures of the eyeliner on my eye's, they are in the same order as on my hand.
Benefit Bad Gal eyeliner = £14.00, Bourjois Smoky = £5.49 and Neal Yards = £9.50

Personally my fav is the Bourjois eyeliner, it goes on really easily and is super black. The brush is fab in helping create a smoky look and its fairly cheap too. Next I would say Bad Gal, this one isn't so black, handy if you don't want an extreme black line, it doesn't go on quite as easily as Bourjois and takes a bit more building up, but its still good. I use this for daytime quite a lot. Coming in last I would have to say Neal Yards, yes its organic so that's a bonus, no nasties! but it takes so much building up and isn't that striking at all, but if you want a really soft look then this could be for you. Please note in the pictures I have no mascara on so you get the full impact of just the eyeliner...hope this was useful xxxx